MAGICDOOR VS RENTREDI

Why MagicDoor’s per-lease pricing loses to RentRedi

Flat rate beats per-lease math as you grow.

✓Flat $12/mo — not $2.50 per active lease
✓$1 ACH vs ~$2.49 per payment
✓Spanish apps · cash rent · Zillow included

Try Risk-Free →

30-day money-back guarantee · No contracts · Cancel anytime

RENTREDI VS MAGICDOOR

MAGICDOOR VS RENTREDI

RentRedi vs TurboTenant Pricing

Flat rate beats per-lease math as you grow.

✓Flat $12/month, half the price of TurboTenant Pro at 11 units
✓No per-door tier jumps at 11, 31, or 61+ doors
✓All features on every plan, built for landlords to scale

Try Risk-Free →

30-day money-back guarantee · No contracts · Cancel anytime

RENTREDI VS MAGICDOOR

Built for landlords to scale

MagicDoor’s AI is sharp. The per-lease bill climbs.

Free to 10 leases, then $2.50/lease. At 20 leases you’re near $50/mo; at 60 near $150/mo — before $2.49 ACH. RentRedi Grow stays $12/mo.

$12

RentRedi

/mo · unlimited doors

4.8/5

Trusted by 100K+ landlords

$50

MagicDoor

/mo · ~20 leases example

Flat $12/mo vs MagicDoor at $2.50 × 20 leases (~$50/mo)

Screen & Lease Tenants

Full tenant screening with credit, criminal, and eviction reports, plus income verification through TransUnion. Syndicate listings to Zillow and top sites, then e-sign unlimited leases with automatic renewal reminders.

Collect Rent Online

Accept ACH, credit card, and cash payments with AutoPay, reminders, and automated late fees built in. Payout owners, vendors, and anyone else your business needs — from one dashboard.

Streamline Maintenance Requests

Tenants submit maintenance requests with photo and video, so nothing gets lost in translation. AI-powered triage routes each request to the right vendor, or partner with RentRedi for full-service repairs.

Automate Rental Accounting

AI-powered rental property accounting with receipt capture, Schedule E summaries, and automated P&L. Track cash flow, cash-on-cash returns, and equity by property or across your portfolio.

Try RentRedi Risk-Free

Built for landlords to scale

RentRedi is half the price for the same operating stack.

TurboTenant might look affordable when you're starting out — but it taxes your success as soon as you scale past 10 doors.

$12

RentRedi

/mo · unlimited doors

4.8/5

Trusted by 100K+ landlords

$50

MagicDoor

/mo · ~20 leases example

Flat $12/mo vs TurboTenant Pro at $33/mo (11–30 doors)

Screen & Lease Tenants

Collect Rent Online

Accept ACH, credit card, and cash payments with AutoPay, reminders, and automated late fees built in. Payout owners, vendors, and anyone else your business needs — from one dashboard.

Streamline Maintenance Requests

Automate Rental Accounting

AI-powered rental property accounting with receipt capture, Schedule E summaries, and automated P&L. Track cash flow, cash-on-cash returns, and equity by property or across your portfolio.

Try RentRedi Risk-Free

Exclusive partnerships

Exclusive member access for NAR’s 1.5 million REALTORS®

Official property management platform for BiggerPockets Pro — 3 million landlords

The tools you actually need

The real cost of per-lease pricing

AI-native is impressive. Flat pricing still wins at scale.

RentRedi

$12/mo

Try Risk-Free

MagicDoor

$2.50/mo

Try Risk-Free

The tools you actually need

The real cost of scaling

Benchmarked pricing and features for landlords scaling past 10 units. Flat pricing that doesn't climb with every door band.

RentRedi

$12/mo

Try Risk-Free

MagicDoor

$2.50/mo

Try Risk-Free

Past the free 10 leases

Per-lease pricing taxes portfolio growth.

MagicDoor wins on Genie AI and trust accounting. RentRedi wins on predictable cost, lower ACH, Spanish UI, and cash rent as you add doors.

With RentRedi

$12/mo flat for the full operating stack
$1 ACH · Zillow included
Spanish apps · cash via Chime · cancel anytime

With MagicDoor pricing

$2.50 per active lease after 10 free
~$2.49 ACH per transaction
English UI · no cash retail payments

“I love how easy they've made it, for not only my tenants but myself.”— Dawid Yhisrael-Reas, NASA Engineer managing 5 rentals in El Paso, TX

Try RentRedi Risk-Free

Scaling past 10 doors

TurboTenant taxes your success — RentRedi doesn't.

At 11 units, TurboTenant Pro costs $33/mo ($399/yr). RentRedi Grow is $12/mo flat with every feature included.

With RentRedi

$12/mo flat for the full operating stack
$1 ACH · Zillow included
Spanish apps · cash via Chime · cancel anytime

With MagicDoor pricing

$2.50 per active lease after 10 free
~$2.49 ACH per transaction
English UI · no cash retail payments

“I love how easy they've made it, for not only my tenants but myself.”— Dawid Yhisrael-Reas, NASA Engineer managing 5 rentals in El Paso, TX

Try RentRedi Risk-Free

Trusted by Landlords Managing Billions in Assets

4.8/5 average rating

$35B+

Assets Under Management

20+ Awards

Proven Track Record

99%

On-Time Payment Rate

200K+

Landlords & Tenants

"I work 12-hour shifts. I don't have time to chase rent or deal with maintenance chaos. RentRedi runs on autopilot so I can focus on my patients."

Katherine Daly, ICU Nurse

manages 30 rentals in San Diego, CA

“This app is great because a 5-year old could figure it out. My little nephew could figure it out. If he can figure it out, I can figure it out. It's awesome.”

Scott Leo & Jacob Heckford Investments

manages 60+ rentals in Winnsboro, LA

“We had one house that I put on the market on a Friday and it was gone by a Tuesday...We love RentRedi, it's definitely helped us grow our business.”

Amanda Shirley, Realtor & Owner

manages 11 properties in Argyle, TX

RentRedi data

Better tenants. Faster payments.

Real payment behavior from RentRedi landlords — not marketing fluff.

Tenant screening

90%

90% of screened tenants pay on time

That's 7 points higher than unscreened tenants, and they pay 17 days faster.

Auto-pay

99%

99% of tenants on auto-pay pay on time

Even tenants with poor or fair credit hit a 99% on-time rate with auto-pay.

Rent reporting

93%

93% on-time payments with rent reporting

Tenants using RentRedi's rent-reporting feature pay on time 94% of the time, compared with 82% without it.

Frequently asked questions

RentRedi vs MagicDoor: Straight answers for property managers

Honest answers on pricing and features for landlords weighing options beyond MagicDoor.

MagicDoor is free up to 10 active leases, then $2.50 per active lease per month. At ~5 leases/year that’s near RentRedi’s $12/mo; at 20 leases it’s ~$50/mo; at 60 it’s ~$150/mo. RentRedi Grow stays $12/mo flat.

Yes — MagicDoor includes trust accounting and owner portal at all tiers. RentRedi does not currently offer dedicated trust accounting or an owner portal.

MagicDoor lists about $2.49 per ACH. RentRedi is $1 flat. That gap compounds every payment cycle.

MagicDoor offers real-time AI message translation, but the app UI is English-only and there’s no cash-at-retail option. RentRedi has native Spanish apps and cash rent via Chime at 100,000+ locations.

If you want agentic AI (Genie), trust accounting, and owner portals from day one — and your lease count stays small — MagicDoor’s free tier can fit. Switch when per-lease pricing and ACH fees outpace RentRedi’s flat rate.

When per-lease pricing starts taxing growth, choose RentRedi

Try RentRedi risk-free: flat $12/mo, $1 ACH, Zillow, cash rent, and Spanish apps.

Try Risk-Free

Grow from $12/mo · Unlimited units · Cancel anytime

When per-lease pricing starts taxing growth, choose RentRedi

Try RentRedi risk-free: Zillow reach, cash rent, a Spanish app, and accounting that doesn’t wait for Pro.

Try Risk-Free

Grow from $12/mo · Unlimited units · Cancel anytime

Product

Company

Legal

Product

Company

Legal